Bottom Line

The Yaktrax Walk excels as a lightweight, ultra-affordable option for casual winter outings. It delivers solid traction on winter sidewalks, packed snow, and gentle terrain. We tested our pair over multiple Rocky Mountain winters on icy parking lots, urban paths, and mixed hiking terrain. Their close-to-ground feel and smooth surface transitions were consistently reliable in low-angle conditions. Their biggest strengths are weight, simplicity, and widespread availability.

However, the limitations of these winter traction devices becomes obvious on steeper or uneven terrain. The coils don’t bite into hard ice like true spikes, the basic harness can shift or pop off, and durability leaves a lot to be desired. Aggressive or frequent hikers will likely burn through pairs faster than they’d like.

Overall, the Yaktrax Walk offers good value for occasional, predictable winter use, especially for those who want lightweight traction they can throw in a pack and forget about. If you need more security or longevity, you’ll find better options in our guide to the best ice cleats.

How We Tested

Our backyard of the Colorado Rockies is the perfect testing ground for ice cleats, and we thoroughly put them through the paces. From frozen alpine lakes to ski area parking lots, we tested the Yaxtrax Walk for traction, fit, durability, and more.

Traction

The Yaktrax Walk offers moderately aggressive traction with its 1.2 mm steel coils – a design that’s different from the studs and cleats found on most winter traction devices. This coil system provides a close-to-ground feel, which is great for transitioning between wet and dry surfaces. But it also sacrifices a bit of bite on steeper or more technical terrain.

On most surfaces you’ll encounter around town – ice, packed snow, and light, loose snow – the Walk performs better than you’d expect. The coils give an extra edge of stability and just enough confidence as long as the path stays relatively flat. 

Once the grade increases, though, the limits of this design start to show. They can limit the amount of skating but have nothing to bite into ice. They’re not as safe as spike-based systems on icy or steep terrain.

Overall, the Yaktrax Walk is ideal for everyday winter use like walking the dog, commuting to work, or navigating icy sidewalks and parking lots. For true winter hiking or uneven trails, you’ll want to step up to a more aggressive cleat with real spikes.

Fit

The Yaktrax Walk fits a wide range of footwear reasonably well, but it’s definitely a “one size fits most” kind of item. The elastic harness isn’t as secure or form-fitting as what you’ll find on higher-end cleats, but it’s still comfortable enough for everyday use. For casual walkers wearing standard shoes or light boots, the overall fit will feel adequate but not locked in.

Our biggest concern with the Walk is with security. The rubber harness has a tendency to shift, especially in uneven terrain, and it can even pop off if it catches the wrong angle. The gap along the arch – as well as the steel coils themselves – are prone to snagging on rocks and sticks, creating a potential tripping hazard on rugged trails. The Yaktrax Walk requires a little more careful fitting and adjustment overall than other ice cleats.

Ease of Use/Versatility

The Yaktrax Walk features a very simple design, but sometimes they take a little eyeballing to get them aligned correctly. They have a tendency to flip inside out when packed, and while the toe and heel are faintly marked, it’s not immediately obvious which end is which. This is annoying when using them in the dark. 

The toe basket sits right at the very tip of the shoe rather than wrapping over the top, which makes the Walk a little harder to slip into. Even once they’re on, they usually need a final wiggle and adjustment to lock in fully before you start walking.

In use, the Walk performs better for casual winter walking. Packed snow is where they excel, offering reliable, confidence-boosting grip on moderate paths and trails. On steeper icy sections, traction becomes dicey, and in loose snow, the coils can collect buildup that reduces their bite.

Weight/Packability

The best part of the Yaktrax Walk is how impressively lightweight and affordable they are. At just 3.9 ounces for the pair, they’re the lightest winter traction devices on our list, making them an easy choice for anyone who wants added traction without adding noticeable weight. They keep weight to a minimum – in your pack and on your feet – which is a nice perk for all-day wear.

However, they could be a little more packable. For such a minimalist design, the Walks are surprisingly bulky and have a habit of flipping inside out or tangling with other gear. Since they don’t come with a stuff sack, it’s easy for them to snag or get lost in your pack. We recommend tossing them in a small sack of your own or strapping them to the outside of your bag when not in use.

Durability

Durability is undeniably the Walk’s weakest point. We’ve  gone through several pairs of these ice cleats traversing icy parking lots in the winter, snapping coils and elastic harnesses. Once a coil or strap fails, these Yaktrax are unusable.

The upside is that the Yaktrax Walk is both inexpensive and widely available, making replacements quick and painless. Although we prefer gear that lasts – and stays out of the landfill – the Walks are easy to replace on short notice with minimal blow to the wallet.

Should You Buy the Yaktrax Walk?

The Yaktrax Walk is best suited for people who need a simple, lightweight boost in traction for everyday winter outings. Think walking the dog, commuting on icy sidewalks, or navigating packed-snow paths around town. They prioritize minimal weight, easy transitions between surfaces, and a simple, no-frills design. If you mostly stick to flat or gently rolling terrain and want something that adds confidence without feeling heavy or overbuilt, the Walk serves that purpose well.

However, it’s not the right choice for hikers, runners, or anyone venturing onto steep, uneven, or icy trails. The coil-based traction and basic harness aren’t secure or aggressive enough for steep or rocky terrain, and the durability simply isn’t up to frequent or high-demand use.

In terms of value, the Walk offers good bang for the buck for casual winter travel. It’s inexpensive, widely available, and feather-light, making it easy to justify as a convenience item. But those who need long-term durability or reliable grip in variable terrain will get far better value from a more robust, spike-based cleat.

What Other Traction Devices Should You Consider?

Be sure to check out our full winter traction guide to find the perfect pair of ice cleats for your needs.

Kahtoola NANOspikes Review: We like the NANOspikes better for running as they are lightweight, have strategically placed concave studs, and a grippier plastic sole. The concave stud shape provides better grip at every angle – although, they aren’t replaceable. 

Black Diamond Distance Spike Review: The Distance Spike will keep you in the realm of ultralight gear while providing much more serious traction and a superior fit. It’s a substantial upgrade in performance and durability over the Yaktrax Walk, but that jump in quality comes with a significantly higher price tag.

Yaktrax Diamond Grip Review: The Diamond Grips are also comfy under foot, but are best suited for sticky snow that tends to accumulate on your shoe or cleats. The beaded design allows the spikes to spin freely, constantly shedding excess snow. If your main concerns are durability and security, the Ice Runners are still your best bet.

Bottom Line

The Korkers Ice Runner provides a secure, reliable fit, excellent durability, and smooth transitions across a variety of winter surfaces. We tested these cleats across every type of terrain we could find in the Colorado Rockies, and their BOA tightening system and wraparound harness held fast every time. The replaceable carbide studs and strong steel cables add durability and longevity, making these cleats a solid long-term investment.

The main limitations are traction and bulk. The forward toe spike sits further back than ideal, and the absence of studs under the arch creates weak points on slick surfaces, so they aren’t ideal for running, steep hills, or deep snow. They’re also heavier and bulkier than most cleats. They’re best suited for putting on at the start of the day and leaving them on until you’re done hiking.

They’re not the cheapest cleats, but their replaceable parts and super secure fit make them a strong value. For a broader view of top-performing options, check out our guide to the best ice cleats.

How We Tested

We covered dozens of trail miles in the Rocky Mountains with the Ice Runners, testing every type of terrain we could find. We took them through deep snow, packed snow, ice, and variable surfaces to assess every aspect of their design. In addition, each piece of gear gets an up close look in a controlled setting to verify quantifiable testing metrics.

Traction

The Korkers Ice Runner features 11 carbide studs across the forefoot and heel, offering light traction on ice, packed snow, and other winter surfaces. For everyday activity or casual walks on packed snow, these cleats perform adequately, providing enough grip to give you an extra edge on slippery ground.

The studs do bite into ice when they make good contact, but they tend to miss from time to time. The forwardmost toe spike sits further back toward the ball of the foot than we’d like, and there’s only one. Consequently, we felt a noticeable and consistent slip when pushing off the toe. The absence of studs beneath the arch creates another weak point, and when the studs miss, you’re left with a slippery plastic between your soles and the slippery surface.

Despite these limitations, the Ice Runner transitions well between surfaces, moving smoothly from snow to wet pavement without catching or dragging. Although marketed as a running ice cleat, the combination of slippery plastic and sparse stud placement makes traction somewhat unpredictable, and we wouldn’t recommend running in them.

Fit

Thanks to its BOA tightening mechanism, the Ice Runner provides a secure and reliable fit across a wide range of footwear. We tried them on trail runners, hiking shoes, and mid-weight hiking boots and the Ice Runner never felt out of place.

These are some of the most secure ice cleats we’ve tested. Once you slide these babies on and get the BOA cinched down tight, they stay put all day long. The BOA cables resist loosening over time and the wraparound harness makes ample contact with your shoe. 

Our only complaint is that the fit isn’t tailored to any one shoe type. The harness is generously roomy, which is great for accommodating bulkier boots, but smaller shoes can leave a gap, especially around the toe. The forward toe section can shift or wrinkle if your shoe doesn’t fully fill the harness, which may feel a little awkward. Despite this, the Ice Runner remains impressively secure.

Ease of Use/Versatility

The Ice Runners are straightforward to use and transition effortlessly across varied terrain. The front is unmistakable from the back and the harness opens up super wide for an effortless entry. 

In addition to its precise fit and excellent security, the BOA system is very simple to use. Once your foot is in, just push down the BOA wheel and turn it clockwise until it feels nice. Releasing is as simple as pulling the wheel out until you hear a satisfying click. The handy pull tabs on the upper and the heel aren’t too shabby either. 

As long as you stay away from the steeps, the Ice Runners can handle most surfaces with ease. We were delighted by how shoe-like they felt on dry surfaces. They don’t mess with your gait or feel like platform shoes. However, proceed with caution with navigating icy hills or venturing into deep snow.

Weight/Packability

The Korkers Ice Runner isn’t exactly an ultralight’s dream. It’s a bit heavier and bulkier than most other ice cleats, which is surprising considering its light traction.

The pair weighs in at 14.8 ounces – nearly a half pound for each foot. That’s a significant weight to consider, especially if you’re planning on running in them or tackling big miles. 

The tradeoff for the Ice Runner’s exceptionally secure fit and versatility is bulk. The wraparound harness and BOA cables take up a fair amount of space in your pack, and the cables themselves create an obvious tangling hazard. A stuff sack would make packing a little easier, but you’ll have to bring your own since Korkers does not provide one with the cleats. 

These cleats are really meant to be put on at the beginning of the day and left on until you make it to camp or the car. They’re not the pair to carry with you all day just to break out of your pack when the terrain gets tough.

Durability

The thick plastic harness, 49-strand steel BOA cables, and carbide studs make the Ice Runners some of the most durable ice cleats that we’ve tested.

The cables theoretically have the tensile strength to hold several adult humans before breaking. The carbide studs are also incredibly strong and abrasion resistant but are made to be replaced if they were to break or fall out. That means that the main body of the cleat should be able to outlast multiple sets of replacement cleats.

The only caveat is the BOA cables themselves. If one were to fail, they aren’t easily repairable in the field. Any breakage would likely require sending the cleats back to Korkers for repair or replacement. While this is a minor inconvenience for casual users, it’s worth noting for those relying on the Ice Runner in remote or extended backcountry situations.

Should You Buy the Korkers Ice Runner?

The Korkers Ice Runner is ideal for winter adventurers who prioritize a secure, reliable fit over ultralight weight. These cleats are ideal for day trips, casual hikes, and everyday walks on packed snow or gentle icy paths, where you need just a little edge in stability and confident footing. Thanks to the BOA tightening system and wraparound harness, the Ice Runner stays firmly in place on a variety of shoe types, from trail runners to mid-weight hiking boots, making them one of the most secure cleats we’ve tested.

That said, they’re not the cleats for runners, steep hills, or deep snow unless you’re very confident in your footing. The forward toe spike is positioned further back, and the absence of studs under the arch creates unfortunate weak points, making traction a little unpredictable on tricky terrain.

For those who use them in the right context, the Ice Runner represents excellent value. Their durability, replaceable carbide studs, and secure fit make them a long-lasting option, and their stability and ease of use outweigh the bulk for most people. These are best put on at the start of the day and left on until your outing ends.

What Other Traction Devices Should You Consider?

Be sure to check out our full winter traction guide to find the perfect pair of ice cleats for your needs.

Kahtoola NANOspikes Review: We like the NANOspikes better for running as they are lightweight, have strategically placed concave studs, and a grippier plastic sole. The concave stud shape provides better grip at every angle – although, they aren’t replaceable. 

Yaktrax Walk Review: The Walks are slightly more noticeable under foot, but provide slightly better traction on ice over the Ice Runners. Besides that, they serve essentially the same purpose with a smaller price tag but significantly less durability.

Yaktrax Diamond Grip Review: The Diamond Grips are also comfy under foot, but are best suited for sticky snow that tends to accumulate on your shoe or cleats. The beaded design allows the spikes to spin freely, constantly shedding excess snow. If your main concerns are durability and security, the Ice Runners are still your best bet.

Bottom Line

The Black Diamond Access Spikes deliver excellent traction, a secure fit, and all-day comfort, making them the top-performing ice cleats in our guide to the best traction devices. On our test hikes through variable, early winter conditions in Colorado, they consistently impressed with their stability and reliable harness that never slipped or created pressure points.

Their biggest strengths are their hiking-focused performance and ease of use. They bite confidently into packed snow and moderate ice. Plus, the enclosed toe box keeps your foot locked in place, and the included stuff sack adds real convenience for packing.

Their main downsides are tied to versatility. They feel awkward on long stretches of dry ground, and they’re not built for technical mountaineering or mixed rock and ice travel. Still, for hikers who stick to snowy trails, they offer strong overall value – lightweight, secure, and dependable without being too costly.

How We Tested

We tested these cleats during early winter hikes in the Colorado Front Range when alpine lakes were just starting to freeze and the ground was full of mixed winter conditions. We slogged through slush, crust, ice and thin coverage to assess every aspect of their design.

Traction

The Black Diamond Access Spikes provide excellent traction for all day hikes in a variety of conditions and surfaces. The fourteen, well-spaced, 8 mm stainless steel spikes offer secure grip on packed snow and ice and even help paddle through softer, looser snow.

The Access Spikes feel at home on the trail whether it’s flat, rolling, or moderately steep mountain terrain. The three spikes mounted at the very front of the toe bite into inclines, giving you a little extra purchase on ascents. 

These strengths make the Access Spikes an excellent choice for hikers tackling typical winter routes, but they’re not designed for more extreme objectives. Their traction and harness aren’t built for technical scrambling, high-consequence mountaineering, or extended rock-and-ice terrain. They also feel slightly awkward on long stretches of bare ground. The spikes really need some ice or snow to dig into for smooth, efficient walking.

Fit

The Access Spikes use a tried-and-true harness design among top ice cleat manufacturers – and for good reason. The full-coverage elastomer wraps up and over the top of the foot, creating a snug, uniform hug that stays comfortable all day long. In our testing on long winter hikes, the Access Spikes never slipped, loosened, or caused pressure points. They simply locked in and stayed put, even on uneven and steep terrain.

One of the biggest failure points we see with other cleats is the toe area. It’s often too tight, which causes discomfort. Or it’s too loose, which allows the shoe to drift and compromises traction. We appreciate Black Diamond’s almost fully enclosed toe box that cups the front of your shoe securely. It prevents your toe from sliding forward and eliminates the risk of poking through the harness on descents.

Overall, the Access Spikes are built for all-day, worry-free comfort and stability. Their dependable fit is one of the standout reasons they work so well for long winter adventures.

Ease of Use/Versatility

Although the Access Spikes aren’t ideal for everyday use, they offer excellent hiking-focused versatility. They’re also refreshingly simple to use. The toe and heel are clearly defined, which cuts down on fumbling when you’re gearing up in the cold, and the dual pull tabs make it easy to stretch the harness into place without pinching your fingers. Once on, they feel secure and ready for action.

The Access Spikes do most things well — but not everything. They deliver dependable traction for the full spectrum of winter hiking as long as there’s at least some snow or ice underfoot. On dry concrete or bare pavement, though, the spikes feel awkward and slightly unstable, which makes them less suited for casual, around-town errands. These are purpose-built tools for hikers who spend their winters on real trails, not city sidewalks. In their recommended context, they perform exactly as you’d hope.

Weight/Packability

At just 9.3 ounces for the pair, plus an included stuff sack, the Black Diamond Access Spikes give the competition a real run for their money. Dedicated ultralight backpackers may still find them a touch heavy for long-distance trips, but they land comfortably within lightweight territory and strike an excellent balance between low weight and aggressive, confidence-inspiring traction. At roughly 4.4 extra ounces per foot, they add very little bulk to your stride.

The included stuff sack is a welcome addition, especially since ice cleats have a bad habit of snagging or tangling with other gear when tossed loosely into a pack. With the sack keeping everything contained, the Access Spikes compress down to roughly the size of a baseball — easy to stash, easy to grab, and far tidier than other competitors.

Durability

Several users have noted reduced longevity in the Access Spikes compared to the Kahtoola MICROspikes, probably due to their lightweight design. But so far, we haven’t had any issues.

The elastomer harness retains its stretchiness without cracking even in subfreezing temperatures. The hardened stainless steel spikes and chains should have no problem holding up to years of normal use. The stitching is also solid, and the chain attachment points are reinforced with hard plastic.

As long as you treat them with a reasonable amount of care, the Access Spikes should last for a good while.

Should You Buy the Black Diamond Access Spike?

The Black Diamond Access Spikes are an excellent match for hikers who don’t let winter get in the way of crushing miles. These spikes power through most winter terrain – whether it’s packed snow, rolling terrain, or moderately steep mountain routes. They shine when there’s at least some ice or snow underfoot, offering reliable traction, all-day comfort, and a secure fit.

They’re not ideal for technical mountaineering, mixed rock-and-ice travel, or everyday use around town. The spikes simply aren’t serious enough for high-consequence objectives and are awkward and overkill for slushy sidewalks.

In terms of value, the Access Spikes hit a sweet spot for hikers who want high performance without unnecessary weight or complexity. They offer excellent traction, a standout fit, and convenient packability at a reasonable price point. They may not be the most durable model on the market, but typical winter hikers can’t go wrong with the Access Spikes.

What Other Traction Devices Should You Consider?

Be sure to check out our full winter traction guide for options across the entire traction spectrum. 

Kahtoola MICROspikes Review: A longtime favorite, the Kahtoola MICROspikes invented the tried and true design the Access Spike now uses. The main difference with the Kahtoola is increased durability and traction in a slightly heavier package. 

Black Diamond Distance Spike Review: The Distance Spike features the same level of aggressive traction while being much more running focused. The harness is lighter, more comfortable, and a touch more secure on trail runs. The downside is decreased durability due to the lighter materials.

Kahtoola EXOspikes Review: The EXOspikes represent an excellent middle ground between casual traction and hiking traction. They’re light enough to run in yet surprisingly grippy on steep terrain. They also maintain a low profile that doesn’t feel overly awkward when transitioning to dry surfaces.

Bottom Line

The Dream Pairs Mid-Calf boots are an excellent budget option for beginners or those looking to save money. When we tested these boots alongside other models in real-world conditions, we found that despite some flaws, they offer good performance for the price.

We were pleased to see that these boots are quite light for their size, weighing only 18 ounces or 1.2 pounds. The lightweight design was noticeable during walking or hiking. We could wear them for hours without experiencing fatigue. Another impressive feature was the traction, which was surprisingly good considering the low profile of the tread.

We do wish these boots had better water resistance and warmth. Some of this is due to materials that are less expensive than those used in other women’s winter boots on the market. We also got a bad blister at one point because the boots lost their shape.

Overall, buyers should be prepared for reduced durability over the long term, correlating with the lower price point. However, we believe most of the other negatives can easily be addressed and that these boots perform well enough to more than justify the price point. If these aren’t the type of winter boots you’re looking for, check out our full list of women’s winter boots.

How We Tested

We wore the Dream Pairs boots around Durango, Colorado, during casual walks, at the office, and on snow hikes. The walk and hike distances were usually around five miles each time, although we also wore them for up to 12 hours during the day.

Weight

The Dream Pairs Mid-Calf Boots are surprisingly lightweight for a taller, snow-compatible boot. When we weighed one, it came in at 18 ounces, just over a pound. Compared to other tall boots like the Bogs Arcata and Sorel Caribou, the Dream Pairs are nearly a pound lighter boot. 

The difference in weight is noticeable on the trail. The lighter design makes it easier to maneuver on snowy and dry surfaces alike. We really appreciated this when playing with our dog during a hike in the San Juan mountains. It also results in less foot fatigue when worn for long periods.

We wore these boots for over 12 hours one day at our office job, and they felt about the same as wearing a regular work shoe. One thing to keep in mind is that some of the weight reduction probably comes from cheaper, less durable materials. However, considering the price point, the lightweight design is a big advantage for these boots.

Water Resistance

For brief or mild water exposure, the Dream Pairs Mid-Calf boots are adequate, but don’t expect them to withstand large amounts. To evaluate water resistance, we submerged each boot from our lineup in a bathtub filled with enough water to cover the toe. We used rocks to weigh down the boots. Every five minutes or so, we checked for signs of water ingress and noted the time when they became wet.

During this test, we found that the Dream Pairs boots were completely wet inside in less than 35 minutes. They had standing water inside at that point and probably wetted out a bit earlier. This is disappointing and would be a serious problem while hiking. 

Based on our experience with these boots, they do stay dry with minimal water. We used them while walking on a recreational path during a light drizzle, and they stayed warm and dry the entire two-hour walk.

Likewise, we deliberately tried to walk through puddles during testing, and they always remained dry during those quick submersions. Overall, we wouldn’t rely on these boots in wet climates or areas with large amounts of standing water, but they are adequate for snow or drier conditions areas.

Warmth

Although the Dream Pairs website claims a temperature rating of -25°F, the Mid-Calf boots fell short in warmth during testing. To evaluate warmth, we placed these boots in a snow drift to monitor the internal temperature over 30 minutes. They started fairly warm, but the inside temperature quickly dropped, placing them near the bottom of our lineup.

In real-world conditions, we found the warmth to be sufficient for moderate winter weather. Walking around town in drizzle, shoveling snow, and hiking in sunny conditions near Durango, Colorado, were all comfortable while wearing the Dream Pairs boots. The faux fur and knitted collar also provide a cozy feeling of warmth. However, for extreme conditions or situations where warmth is critical, we would likely opt for another option.

Comfort

Comfort with the Dream Pairs Mid-Calf boots can vary depending on usage and limited features. We ranked each boot based on the number of comfort features to provide a fair comparison across our lineup. We appreciate that the Dream Pairs boots are available in sizes 5-12 and can be returned if they do not feel comfortable.

The ability to adjust the fit with laces and the faux fur lining are also positive aspects of this model. Additionally, the knit collar offers a unique comfort feature. However, improvements could include offering half sizes, removable inserts, and a wider toe box. 

Our experience walking and hiking in these boots was very inconsistent. Some days, we could walk for hours without any foot fatigue or rubbing. However, on one occasion, we experienced severe rubbing on the Achilles tendons of both feet while wearing these boots.

During a five-mile walk in rainy conditions, blisters formed that took over a week to heal. We were able to wear these boots again without rubbing afterward, but we recommend wearing thicker socks with them to prevent blisters. Since the blisters were caused by material quality and craftsmanship issues, where the boot shaft folded inward, we deducted some points from the Dream Pairs boots to reflect this problem.

Overall, we believe that being aware of the limitations of budget boots and adjusting layering accordingly can help reduce some of the negatives for those seeking an affordable option boot.

Traction

The Dream Pairs Mid-Calf boots have average traction with lackluster tread. When evaluating traction, tread pattern is important. Specifically, we look for increased surface area to improve grip on slick surfaces.

The Dream Pairs boots don’t have much tread height, although they do have a fair amount of texture. We didn’t expect much grip, but we were surprised to see an average performance during our side-by-side traction test. When we placed these boots on the rock of the traction arm and lifted, they stayed put long enough to beat half of the boots in our previous test lineup. 

While wearing these boots on ice patches around Durango, Colorado, we found their performance to be unremarkable. Nothing notable stood out, whether good or bad. The same was true when hiking on snowy trails near Purgatory ski area. Our overall experience with the Dream Pairs boots on slick surfaces was neutral.

Should You Buy the Dream Pairs Mid-Calf Boots?

The Dream Pairs aren’t perfect, but there’s a reason we listed them among the best winter hiking boots: value. These boots cost 2-5 times less than other boots in our selection.

They offer an affordable option that still performs well, making them a good choice for beginners or those needing something for now. We recommend them for people who need a boot that works in snowy or dry conditions and who don’t mind replacing them eventually when they wear out.

What Other Women’s Winter Boots Should You Consider?

We’ve tested many boots, so if you’re unsure about the Dream Pairs, check out some of these other options from women’s winter boot gear guide:

Sorel Caribou Review: Tried and true, the Sorel Caribou boots are a classic winter choice. Similar in design to the Dream Pairs, but made with higher-quality materials, those with a larger budget might want to splurge or upgrade to these instead.

Ugg Adirondack III Review: Another boot with a similar design, but a higher price, the Ugg Adirondack boots score well in our tests. The wool lining makes these boots incredibly warm, and they performed well in the water resistance test. Just be prepared for the additional cost materials.

Columbia Minx Shorty Review: The Columbia Minx Shorty boots are another favorite budget option of ours. Like the Dream Pairs, they tend to wet out quickly and aren’t as warm as some other choices. However, they are comfortable and lightweight, offering a lot of value table.

Bottom Line

Xtratuf boots are beloved in winter climates for their excellent traction and waterproof design. We love our pair of Xtratuf boots, which we bought while living in Alaska, so much that we had to include them in our list of best winter boots. During side-by-side testing, we confirmed much of what we already knew from extensive use. First, they perform great in wet and slippery conditions.

The boots stayed dry after over two hours of submersion in water. They also scored well on our traction measuring device and gave us confidence walking on snow- and ice-covered surfaces. 

Some downsides of the Xtratufs include the lack of insulation, a heavier design, and limited options for customizing comfort. During winter hikes in both Alaska and Colorado, we have noticed that the toes can get a bit chilly while standing around in these boots.

Additionally, the neoprene materials and tall shaft inherently make them weigh more than some other boots.

However, these issues are minimal or easily fixed with thicker socks. Overall, we will always keep a pair of Xtratufs in our closet for rainy days, snowy hikes, and long winter walks on the beach. If these aren’t the type of winter boots you’re looking for, check out our full list of women’s winter boots.

How We Tested

We have been using and hiking in Xtratuf boots for many years, starting with our first pair while living in Alaska. We’ve used these boots for outdoor chores in winter, walks along Katchemak Bay in Homer, AK, and hikes in both the Kenai and San Juan areas. 

Weight

The Xtratuf 15” Legacy boots were some of the heaviest we tested due to their heavier neoprene design and tall shaft height. When we weighed one on our kitchen scale, it came in at 28 ounces, or 1.7 pounds.

This was comparable to most of the other tall rubber boots we evaluated. It was disappointing to see that they weighed slightly more than the Bogs Neo Classic Tall, despite having less insulation.

From our experience, buying Xtratufs that fit well really helps reduce how heavy they feel during use. We’ve been hiking on beaches and in snow with

Xtratufs for years, and boots that are too big can feel quite heavy on your feet in a short time. Properly sized boots are easier to walk in, although they still require more effort than some lighter options models.  

Water Resistance

The Xtratuf 15″ Legacy boots excel in water resistance. Their neoprene design is 100% waterproof, as confirmed through both quantitative and qualitative testing. To compare them with other boots, we placed them in a bathtub filled with water, enough to cover the toes.

After adding a rock to prevent floating, we started a timer and checked the inside every five minutes. The Xtratuf boots remained completely dry after more than two hours in the water. 

One of our favorite uses for these boots is during winter hikes where water is involved. For example, we enjoy walking the beaches near Homer, Alaska, all year round. These boots have always kept our feet dry as long as nothing falls in over the top. On more traditional hikes, they are perfect for stream crossings or wet snow. If moisture is a major concern, then the Xtratuf boots are a fantastic choice.

Warmth

Although the Xtratuf 15″ Legacy boots were made in Alaska and are essentially the state footwear, they lack any insulation and are the coldest among the boots we tested. To evaluate their warmth, we buried the toes and heel in a snowbank and measured the internal temperature with an infrared thermometer. We recorded readings every 5 minutes to compare how temperatures changed over time. From the first measurement, the inside of the Xtratufs was colder than all the other boots. Throughout the test, the temperatures were similar to those of a pair of trail runners we used as a control. 

In the field, we often find the Xtratufs to feel chilly whether hiking the Resurrection Pass trail in Alaska or walking through snow in Colorado’s San Juan Mountains. Part of this is due to the neoprene construction with just a basic inner lining.

We usually try to pair these boots with warmer socks, and it may be helpful to consider that when choosing a size. Although the toes can often feel cold in these boots, it’s less noticeable when moving and has never been a problem when hiking in temperatures down to the low 20’s.

Comfort

The Xtratuf 15″ Legacy boots either will or will not be comfortable, as there are limited ways to address pain points. Since comfort varies greatly between individuals, we focused mainly on the number of adjustment points available to modify the boot’s comfort when ranking models in this category.

Features like laces, a wide range of sizes including half sizes, and the availability of wide toe boxes were among the aspects we looked for, though the Xtratufs lack some of these. However, we were pleased to find that they have removable insoles, allowing orthotics or custom insoles to be added if needed to increase comfort. We also appreciate that they can be returned if they are uncomfortable for the wearer. 

It’s important to note that although the Xtratuf boots didn’t score very high in comfort, we’ve never found them uncomfortable. We’ve spent many days wearing these boots on beach walks in Alaska and on winter hikes without any signs of discomfort. We believe this is true for many people, as these boots are very popular in the Last Frontier state. The only reason we ranked them lower is that if they don’t fit your foot shape well, there’s little that can be done to fix it short of returning them and trying a different pair boot.

Traction

Xtratuf boots are known for their great traction in slippery conditions, which is why they are a top choice for fishermen working on boats in Alaska. The tread on Xtratufs is less aggressive than some dedicated hiking boots but features a lot of surface area. When we tested these boots on our traction device, they climbed up to a 45° slope before slipping and falling. This places them in the upper tier of boots we tested for traction.

Though we can’t claim to have worn them on a wet boat, we have used the Xtratuf boots on various slick surfaces. We have hiked with them over wet rocks on the beach, on wet wharfs, icy roads, and snowy trails. Throughout it all, they have provided reliable traction, and the fall risk has always felt minimized low. 

Should You Buy the Xtratuf 15″ Legacy Boots?

The Xtratuf 15″ Legacy boots have notable strengths and obvious weaknesses to consider before purchasing. Their neoprene build and tall shaft make them ideal for wet conditions, including prolonged submersion. They also offer good traction, which is helpful on wet rocks and ice.

Additionally, they are easy to slip on and off, making them a great choice to keep by the door in winter or as transition shoes before skiing. Those concerned about adjustability, warmth, or lighter weight should look elsewhere however.

What Other Women’s Winter Boots Should You Consider?

Not quite what you’re after? Check out our women’s winter boot gear guide: or some comparable models below:

Bogs Arcata Review: One of our editor’s picks, we love how versatile the Bogs Arcata boots are. Though they aren’t as tall as the Xtratuf boots, they feature handles for easy slip-on, faux-lined fur and insulation for warmth, plus a lighter weight. We appreciate that they remain highly waterproof with decent tread.

Bogs Neo Classic Tall Review: Similar in height and featuring a waterproof design, the Bogs Neo Classic Tall boots are a great alternative to the Xtratuf boots. Those seeking extra warmth will appreciate the insulated design of these Bogs. 

Sorel Caribou Review: Like the Xtratuf boots, the Sorel Caribou has a long-standing reputation for quality and performance. These boots are designed with snow in mind for those who want warmer boots with more adjustability.

Bottom Line

The Salomon Toundra Pro boots are one of our favorite winter boots for hikes in rugged conditions. To test them out, we conducted a series of side-by-side experiments and wore them on hikes around Durango, Colorado, as well as into the office.

One thing we discovered through these tests is that these boots have incredible tread! Not only did they excel on our traction machine, but we have never felt as secure walking on ice as we did in these boots. Another area of praise is the warm insulation and faux fur lining. These boots felt warm, sometimes a bit too much so, on all kinds of hikes. 

No piece of gear is perfect. When it comes to the Toundra, we wish they were a bit lighter on the feet. On drier terrain, in particular, they can feel slightly heavy by the end of the hike. It was also disappointing to find out that they will wet out after about an hour of full submersion. However, they perform well with short durations in water. 

Overall, we were impressed with how well these boots performed in a few key areas, and their consistent performance across the board makes them a new favorite on our list of women’s winter boots.

How We Tested

We tested the Toundra boots in the snowy San Juan Mountains of Colorado. These boots were mainly used for day hikes in both dry and snowy conditions. We also wore them to the office and around town to put extra miles on them. 

Weight

The Salomon Toundra Pro boots are similar in weight to, or slightly heavier than, other hiking-specific boots. Some of this can be attributed to the features it offers, such as taller shaft height and aggressive tread. According to our scale, the boots weighed 22 ounces, placing them in the middle of our lineup. This was also consistent with or slightly heavier than many of the other hiking-specific boots we tested, such as the Keen Revel Polar and Oboz Bridger boots. 

On the trails, we found these boots to feel a bit heavy on the feet, especially in drier conditions. In snowy environments, the weight was less noticeable due to the uneven terrain and icy surfaces. That said, hiking in them was a bit more tiring than with some of our lighter models. We also wore these boots for over 8 hours in the office and hardly noticed the weight throughout the day.

The takeaway? These boots are slightly heavy, which can lead to increased fatigue during hikes, even if it’s not immediately apparent. Still, it’s a small tradeoff for some of the other features this boot offers. 

Water Resistance

We were surprised to see the Salomon Toundra boots become wet after just an hour of submersion. Considering their sturdy build and gusseted tongue, we expected them to resist water better. However, during our side-by-side test, they simply didn’t hold up. 

We submerged the boots in water up to the bottom of the tongue and weighed them down with a rock. While monitoring, everything seemed normal until we noticed water seeping in through the side panel. Luckily, the inside of the boot was only damp instead of soaked, but it was enough to get our socks wet. 

During testing, we tried to find opportunities to walk through puddles with these boots. Quick submersions were never enough to soak through, and we had no issues with snow while hiking. This indicates that the Toundra boots are suitable for drier snow and trail conditions, but other boots might be better for long-term use in wet conditions climates.

Warmth

The Salomon Toundra performed well in cold conditions and is one of our top choices for dedicated hiking boots that keep you warm. When we buried these boots in snow for our side-by-side test, we were impressed to see that they matched the performance of the leading boots. We used an infrared thermometer to measure the temperature inside and took readings every five minutes. The temperatures we recorded were higher than average compared to all the other boots we tested. 

In the field, we appreciate how cozy the faux fur is, which lends a feeling of warmth. On early-morning hikes on snow and ice in Durango, Colorado, our feet always stayed warm in these boots with regular hiking socks. Even when plowing through deep powder near Little Molas Lake, our toes remained warm. 

Of course, the trade-off is that these boots can feel a bit too warm during shoulder season hikes. We experienced this firsthand with sweaty feet while hiking the Log Chutes trail system near Durango. Overall, these boots are among our top choices for colder conditions hikes. 

Comfort

For comfort, the Salomon Toundra Pro boots feature multiple adjustability points and a taller shaft height, which result in a better fit. Since comfort is highly subjective from person to person, we focused on customization when comparing different models side-by-side. We rated the Toundra boots based on availability in half sizes, removable insoles, adjustable laces, a return policy, and faux fur lining.

Sizing, insoles, and laces all allow users to personalize or modify these boots for a better fit. We also found that faux fur lining makes the boots feel cozier and more comfortable to wear. The option to return boots that are uncomfortable offers the opportunity to try them out without full commitment. 

In the field, we found these boots to be relatively comfortable to wear. Besides feeling a little heavy in some conditions, we didn’t experience any foot fatigue or find any rub spots. The taller shaft reduces the chances of rubbing on the side of the ankle where the fibula and tibia bones meet the foot. Overall, we like how comfortable they are and will keep wearing them in various situations environments.

Traction

The Salomon Toundra Pro boots are one of our favorites for use on ice and other slick surfaces. We are truly impressed with how these boots performed in both our side-by-side and field tests. When we tested them on our traction device, they stayed on the rock longer than any other boots we tried. This matched our experience in the field, where they showed excellent traction.

We were especially excited to find that they gripped pure ice, the kind created by frequent freezing and thawing of snow, so well that walking a large dog was easy. We have never had such an experience with other boots, and the difference in grip was noticeable when we wore different ones afterward. We would happily recommend these boots for use in terrain where traction matters. 

Should You Buy the Salomon Toundra Pro Boots?

The Salomon Toundra boots have many excellent features that make them suitable for more technical winter hikes. Their warm interior and sturdy tread make hiking on cold, icy terrain easier.

They might feel a bit heavy on the feet, so although this is less noticeable in the snow, other boots could be a better choice where distance matters. Similarly, they can handle brief submersions in water but are not ideal for very wet conditions climates. 

What Other Women’s Winter Boots Should You Consider?

If the Salomon Toundra’s aren’t for you, consider checking out these winter hiking boots that we tested for our women’s winter boot gear guide:

Oboz Bridger 7” Insulated Review: Our top choice for women’s winter boots, the Oboz Bridger boots share many benefits with the Toundras. They are similarly weighted and have excellent tread. They also offer better water resistance and adjustability.

Merrell Thermo Chill Mid Review: Another hiking-focused boot, the Merrell Thermo Chill boots feature a lighter design with decent water resistance. In many ways, they are a less rugged version of the Toundras.

Keen Revel IV Polar Review: The Keen Revel Polar boots are designed for snow hiking, featuring good tread and gaiter attachments. These are another great option for hikes in drier conditions climates.

Bottom Line

The Scarpa Moraine Polar is a rugged winter boot made for serious mountain travel. Its extremely durable outer, paired with a super stiff sole. This makes it perfect for kicking steps in firm ice and snow or for pounding down scree-filled slopes. This boot has quickly proven to be one of our favorites for its durability and foot protection for the most demanding environments.

Although Scarpa may not be a household name in the US hiking world, it’s a powerhouse European brand known for high-quality footwear. The Moraine Polar continues this tradition. It’s supremely durable, withstanding miles of rocks, scree, and snow we encountered on winter hikes without showing a scratch. The Moraine Polar comes equipped with GORE-TEX Storm Laminate construction that keeps water out while keeping our feet dry and happy. These boots may not look as big or warm as others, but the Primaloft Pure insulation punched above its weight, keeping us warm in moderate temperatures.

The Moraine Polar comes with some drawbacks – most noticeably when it comes to comfort. These are the stiffest boots we tested with almost zero flex in the sole when hiking. That’s great for kicking steps or more technical adventures in steep terrain, but they felt clompy and unyielding on flatter terrain. The stiff heel cup gave us hot spots due to how stiff and firm it was. Lacking substantial midsole cushion and coming with a narrow fit, these boots may not fit most foot types. 

Despite these shortcomings, the Moraine Polar is a niche boot that will serve specific purposes in steep terrain well for the dedicated mountain hiker.

How We Tested

We tested the Scarpa Moraine Polar GTX over the course of two months in Alaska’s notoriously frigid winter conditions. From icy hikes to slogging through alpine scree to standing in icy creeks, our tests in real-world environments give you the most comprehensive and reliable analysis possible.

Comfort

The Scarpa Moraine Polar is unique in our lineup because of its extremely stiff sole. Feeling more akin to a mountaineering boot, the Moraine Polar is great for kicking steps up a steep, icy slope or in firm snow. However, this almost unyielding sole makes it less comfortable for flatter terrain. It felt clompy, making our gait feel uncomfortable and less natural than with a more flexible sole. 

The heel cup and ankle cuff were other points of discomfort. We experienced hot spots on our heels and discomfort on our protruding ankle bones due to the extremely stiff construction.

Keeping in line with a more technical mountaineering boot, it also lacks substantial midsole cushioning and is very firm. This left our feet tired after a few hours of hiking. These boots may not be the best fit for those with wider feet as they are very narrow, particularly through the midfoot.

Warmth

The Moraine Polar comes packed with 200grams of  Primaloft Pure insulation. Eschewing the bulk of most winter boots, the Moraine Polar is lightweight and sleek while still being warm enough for most winter temperatures. During our testing, we found that these boots are best for more moderate winter temperatures. They work well for active outings down to ten degrees or for stationary use to around 15 or 20 degrees. We found our toes getting cold in them in the single digits, making them better for not as frigid winter temps. 

These boots are likely not the first choice for deep winter conditions, but their moderate insulation gives them three-season versatility. Or, it’s perfect for someone whose feet tend to run hot during exercise.

Traction

The Moraine Polar is armed with 32 sharp-edged lugs per boot. Widely spaced, they shed snow and easily avoid clumping. The sharp edges of the lugs are great for getting a grip in firm conditions, and the stuff rubber is not only highly durable, but also helps to chip out steps while hiking in steep terrain. 

However, the lugs are relatively shallow compared to other boots, meaning they don’t grip as well in loose snow. The stiff rubber, while giving great durability, doesn’t grip as well on ice as a soft rubber compound does. The Moraine Polar offers solid traction for most instances, but we found ourselves slipping on ice more than we expected.

Weather Resistance

Standing in an icy creek confirmed our suspicion that the Moraine Polar is a superbly weather-resistant boot. The leather outer beads moisture that rolls away quickly, and the GORE-TEX liner kept all water from penetrating to our feet. 

The only weakness of these boots is their relatively short shaft height. These are not our top choice for post-holing as they are quickly overwhelmed in deep snow – and lack a gaiter attachment ring to boost weather resistance.

Durability

For a lightweight boot, the Moraine Polar is one of the most durable we’ve tested. The stiff sole has resisted repeated impact with rocks and scree, leaving no chips or scuff. We love the lightweight yet highly durable leather outer. Kicking rocks was no problem, thanks to its rubber rand, and our feet felt protected no matter the terrain. If your hikes regularly encounter sharp rocks and scree, then the Moraine Polar is one of the best lightweight options to hold up for many more hikes.

Should You Buy The Scarpa Moraine Polar GTX?

Those looking for a stiff boot with minimal cushioning will find the Moraine Polar the perfect fit. Its narrow midfoot shape works better for slender feet, and its extremely stiff construction makes it great for kicking steps in steep snow. However, this may make it lose some of its mass appeal as it is not as comfortable for more casual use. With moderate insulation and a slender profile overall, the Morain Polar works well as a three-season boot or a boot for more moderate winter weather.

What other winter boots should you consider?

Check out our full gear guide for all of our favorite winter hiking boots.

Salomon Crosstrak Powder Review: If the Scarpa Moraine Polar left you wanting more traction, the Crosstrak delivers ultimate traction performance.

Merrell Thermo Chill 2 Mid Review: At a more accessible price, the Thermo Chill 2 Mid is great for anyone looking for an affordable yet still high-performing boot.

KEEN Revel IV Polar Review: Similarly durable, the Revel IV Polar delivers great warmth but with the added durability of leather.

Bottom Line

The North Face Vectiv Fastpack Insulated blurs the lines between trail runner and winter boot, proving that boots don’t have to be clunky and big to be warm and weather-resistant. These slim boots have a great weight-to-warmth ratio, making them an excellent choice for moving fast and staying warm on your next mountain adventure.

One of the most comfortable boots in our guide to winter boots, the Vectiv Fastpack is built with a high-rebound EVA midsole that makes each step supportive and cushioned. Another unique feature contributing to this boot’s all-day comfort is the rockered sole. This creates a rolling feeling while walking, avoiding the clunking and clomping found in other boots. The Vectiv Fastpack quickly became a favorite for all-day adventures, where it kept our feet snug, supported, and comfortable mile after mile. 

The only limit to these versatile boots is their relatively lower shaft height. This made them more vulnerable to being topped by deeper snow, particularly through gaps at the tongue and back of the leg where snow could enter. Despite this small issue, the Vectiv Fastpack has impressive weather resistance throughout the rest of the boot, making it an excellent choice no matter the weather this winter.

How We Tested

Our gear analyst wore and tested The North Face Vectiv Fastpack over the course of 2 months in Alaska’s harsh winter conditions. We wore them while climbing mountains in the Chugach Range, snowshoeing local trails, and using them around town to test them in a range of conditions and environments.

Comfort

From our first hike in these boots, we could immediately tell that they are extremely comfortable. Now, after taking these on multi-hour hikes and testing them over the course of two months, we can say with confidence that The North Face Vectiv Fastpack is one of the most comfortable boots in our lineup. 

They are unique for their rockered sole, a feature not often seen in winter boots. This gives them a rolling feel when walking down the trail, avoiding the clomping commonly felt in winter boots.  The high-rebound EVA midsole is supportive yet lightweight, making this boot feel more like a running shoe than a boot. The only place we felt discomfort was on the shaft of the boot. The two metal lace hooks did press into our ankle bones initially, but that alleviated as the boots broke in further.

Warmth

Filled with 200g Heatseeker synthetic insulation, the Vectiv Fastpack is a trim yet extremely warm boot. We hiked in these in single-digit temperatures and never once experienced cold toes. The insulation extends up the shaft of the boot, increasing the insulation to the ankle as well. For a lightweight boot, we were impressed with the warmth the Vectic Fastpack provides. It proves that low bulk does not equal low warmth, as the synthetic insulation is low volume yet still warm enough for most winter temperatures.

If you want a boot to stand stationary for hours in frigid temperatures, you may opt for something bulkier and warmer. But for active outings, the Vectiv Fastpack was more than warm enough for all the temperatures we encountered while testing in Alaska.

Traction

The traction on the Vectiv Fastpack Insulated is confidence-inspiring and feels steady in a wide range of winter conditions. The outsole uses firm rubber with 4-millimeter lugs that dig into packed snow and mud and provide reasonable grip on ice. The lug pattern offers good braking and climbing grip, and they are widely spaced to shed snow and ice that may otherwise clump and reduce traction. 

The only area where we felt that the Vectiv Fastpack’s traction suffered was in loose, sugary snow. The rockered design, while extremely comfortable for walking, means less surface area makes contact with the ground. This meant that fewer of the lugs were actively engaged with the surface, making the boot somewhat slippery. Although the lugs were plenty deep for most occasions, they lacked that extra depth needed for grip in deep powder.

Weather Resistance

The Vectiv Fastpack delivers reliable protection for cold and damp conditions without feeling bulky or restrictive. The boot is constructed with a waterproof leather outer that repels water and withstands all moisture. We found the waterproof label to be true during testing, whether hiking through snow or standing in an icy creek. 

The only source of weakness for snow and wet to enter these boots is the ankle opening. We found gaps at the front and back of the boot where snow could enter while postholing. We suggest pairing these boots with your favorite gaiters if you’re planning on heading out into deep snow.

Durability

We are impressed with the durability of the Vectiv Fastpack considering its a lightweight boot. The leather outer is extremely durable and firmly welded to the rubber rand, protecting toes from impact. The soft yet supportive midsole has held up with little compaction over time. Withstanding us toe kicking rocks and scraping down boulders, the Vectiv Fastpack proves that light doesn’t equal fragile.

Should You Buy The North Face Vectiv Fastpack Insulated?

The North Face Vectiv Fastpack Insulated is made for anyone planning on logging long days on the trail and requires a comfortable and supportive boot. Its supportive midsole and rockered profile felt comfortable while hiking. This is one of our favorite boots for spending hours on the go for its comfort and durability. Though it has a relatively low shaft height and can let it snow around the ankles, this boot is best for less deep snow or paired with some gaiters to keep them fully weatherproof. Anyone seeking a lightweight boot for fast and light winter missions will find the Vective Fastpack to be a worthy choice.

What other winter boots should you consider?

Check out our full gear guide for all of our favorite winter hiking boots.

Keen Revel IV Review: Slightly heavier than the Vectiv Fastpack, the Revel IV has exceptional durability with leather construction.

Salomon Crosstrak Powder Review: Lightweight, but with a slightly taller shaft height, the Crosstrak Powder is exceptionally weather-resistant.

Sorel Caribou Review: If you’re looking for a boot for the coldest days, the Sorel Caribou has got you covered.

Bottom Line

The Salomon Crosstrak Powder is an exceptionally rugged and weather-resistant boot fit for the most demanding winter environments. Tested in single-digit temperatures – snowshoeing and hiking in Alaska’s deep winter – the Crosstrak Powder withstood whatever we threw at it. Its relatively tall shaft height, combined with supreme weather resistance, makes it a standout choice for long adventures in deep snow.

Armed with some of the most aggressive tread we’ve seen, the Crosstrak Powder has supreme traction for uneven terrain. It also has unique lugs on the midsole, adding traction when sidehilling or walking on uneven terrain. If you are planning hikes in serious rocky, icy, and snowy terrain, then the Crosstrak is the perfect companion. We loved its 7.25-inch shaft height, which is among the tallest for technical winter boots in our lineup. Combined with a gaiter loop in the toe, the Crosstrak Powder provides great coverage for deep snow.

The Crosstrak Powder incorporates Salomon’s signature Quicklace system. However, the laces are excessively long, so cinching and storing them proves to be finicky, particularly while wearing gloves. Although this system can be somewhat cumbersome to use, it kept our feet snug and secure without the need to cinch or retie them during an outing. For an adventure-ready boot that can tackle any condition, check out the Salomon Crosstrak Powder.

How We Tested

We tested the Salomon Crosstrak Powder over two months in Alaska’s frigid winter conditions. We thoroughly evaluated every aspect of this boot while snowshoeing and hiking down to zero degrees to bring the most comprehensive and well-researched analysis possible.

Comfort

Weighing in at 2.5 pounds per pair, the Crosstrak Powder is one of the lightest boots in our lineup. When testing these boots on multi-hour hikes in Alaska’s Chugach Range, we loved how unencumbered they felt. The quicklace system secures the foot from the toes up to the ankle, and we love the micro adjustments this system allows. The boots also open up extremely wide. Two large handles make sliding these boots on and off quick and easy.

However, the laces are excessively long, so stowing them in the lace storage pocket can be tricky, especially with gloves on. It’s worth noting that the Crosstrak Powder runs slightly large, so we recommend sizing down a half size for a less roomy fit. Like most of Salomon’s products, they tend to run on the narrow side, so those with wider feet may not find these to be the best fit for their feet.

Warmth

We used these boots down to zero and had no issues with cold feet.  

We were pleasantly surprised with the warmth the Crosstrak Powder provides for such a lightweight and trim boot. They’re packed with Salomon’s adv.WARM polyester insulation, which surprised us with its low bulk and high warmth. They quickly became our go-to for hikes in zero to twenty degree temperatures. Although these boots lack the negative airspace and serious insulation to keep feet warm when people are standing still all day in single-digit temperatures, they provide the perfect amount of insulation for hiking and moving in cold temperatures for hours at a time.

Traction

The Crosstrak Powder earns top marks for having some of the best traction of any winter boot we tested. The soft rubber compound provides excellent grip on ice, and the deep lugs bite into loose snow while their wide space helps to shed clumping. With tread looking like monster trail running lugs, the boots impressed us with their ability to keep a grip when sidehilling or descending steep and slippery slopes. Another unique feature to increase traction is the wrap-around lugs on the midsole. These help to increase traction while sidehilling or in uneven terrain. The Crosstrak Powder provides exceptional traction -in ice and powder – making it a favorite for any winter adventure in the backcountry.

Weather Resistance

With a measured shaft height of 7.25 inches, the Crosstrak Powder is one of the tallest technical winter boots in our lineup. We loved this for adventures in deeper snow or walking through ice puddles and slush. The polyurethane-coated leather outer is extremely weather-resistant and did not let in a drop of water during our testing. 

The gusseted tongue is sealed and waterproof as well, a common weak point in other boots. However, the top of the tongue was a weakness. When tightened, it flares out, providing an entry point for deep snow. We easily abated this problem by wearing pants over the boots. They come with a gaiter attachment point for further weather resistance. 

The Crosstrak Powder provides excellent weather resistance – whether you’re walking in puddles of slush or power.

Durability

Although many lightweight boots are known to break down quicker, that has not been the case for the Crosstrak Powder. The flex points show no signs of wear, and the lugs – while made of a softer rubber – show no chips or wearing down. During our testing over the course of two months, the Crosstrak Powder has proved to be very durable, proving that low weight doesn’t mean low durability.

Should You Buy the Salomon Crosstrak Powder?

The Salomon Crosstrak Powder has quickly proven itself to be one of our favorite boots for anything from backcountry adventures to staying upright on slippery walks around town. It is perfect for anyone who requires extreme traction, warmth without bulk, and high-quality weather resistance all in a lightweight package. If you’re looking for one boot to do it all, then it’s hard to find a better option than the Crosstrak Powder. If you’re not already familiar with Salomon’s Quicklace system, these boots may be a bit finicky to tighten due to their extra-long laces and hard-to-grip tightening toggle. Despite this small shortcoming, the Crosstrak Powder is a high-quality boot, perfect for demanding adventures and conditions.

What other winter boots should you consider?

Check out our full gear guide for all of our favorite winter hiking boots.

The North Face Vective Fastpack Review: Another boot that feels more like a running shoe, The North Face Vective Fastpack is comfortable for long hikes.

Keen Revel IV Polar Review: With leather construction, the Revel IV is heavier than the Crosstrak, but it offers great weather resistance as well.

Sorel Caribou Review: If you’re looking for something for the coldest days, the Sorel Caribou has got you covered.

Bottom Line

The Crescent Moon EVA foams are a uniquely designed snowshoes that offers excellent walkability, comfort, and ease of use for winter trails. Their innovative construction with dual-density EVA foam makes them a standout option in our lineup of the best snowshoes.

The first thing we noticed when testing the EVA Foams was their extremely rockered design. Almost completely U-shaped, these snowshoes have an aggressive curve in both the tips and the tails. This gives them some of the best walkability of any snowshoe we tested. 

If you’re into the rockered shape of trail running shoes, the EVA Foams similarly roll their way down the trail, allowing for a comfortable gait and even running. These are the only snowshoes we tested with a high enough walkability score that we even took them out for some winter trail runs (not walks) in new snow. The dual-density EVA foam is comfortable and absorbs impact with each footfall. Three simple Velcro straps secure the binding to the feet, making putting these on and off a breeze.

Wearing the Crescent Moon EVA Foams both on and off trail, we quickly found their limit. The highly curved design and flexible foam greatly limit their flotation in deep powder, and anything more than a couple of inches proved encumbering. 

We also found the traction to be lacking on any surface other than packed trail. The EVA foam is molded into lugs, and while armed with six preinstalled studs, they did not bite into deep snow or ice as well as crampons or spikes do. For this reason, we reserve them for packed trails when we want the outing to be comfortable and easy walking. Also, if you’re looking to chat with other trail users, this design is sure to turn heads.

How We Tested

The Crescent Moon EVA Foam snowshoes were tested over the course of two months in Alaska’s harsh winter conditions. We tested these on short hikes, all-day excursions, and even winter trail runs to evaluate their performance. From packed trails to deep powder, our testing is based on rigorous field testing that examines every aspect to bring the most well-rounded and comprehensive review possible.

Flotation

At 24 inches long and 8 inches wide at the widest point in the tip, the Crescent Moon EVA Foam is one of the smallest and lowest surface area snowshoes in our lineup.   The tails taper down sharply, making walking easy, but compromise flotation. Tested on a variety of snow surfaces from firmly packed trails to deep powder, the EVA Foam is best for packed trails. 

The highly rockered design means that more weight is centered on a smaller surface area. When testing these in a foot of new snow, they did not provide the level of flotation needed to make travel easy. While they will get you through a few inches of new snow or help float on loosely packed trails, these are not our first choice for right after a big snow or for off-trail.

Traction

The Crescent Moon EVA Foam has one of the most unique traction systems of any snowshoe in our lineup. More resembling the outsole of a running shoe, the single piece of EVA foam is molded into 75 lugs. Six screw-in studs provide added grip on ice and firm snow. We grabbed these for packed trails or shallow new snow when larger snowshoes would be overkill, but trail shoes and microspikes weren’t enough. 

When we tested the upper limits of the EVA foams, they aren’t well matched for deeper snow. We frequently found ourselves slipping in snow deeper than five inches, especially when trying to climb up steep slopes or descend when more weight was placed on the tails. 

Another cool feature is you can screw in more hex head sheet metal screws or add studs directly into the foam for more traction and grip.

Walkability

The Crescent Moon EVA Foam shines when it comes to walkability. Featuring the most aggressive rockered profile of any snowshoe we tested, their U-shape greatly reduces the floppy, clompiness found in classic snowshoe designs. 

The teardrop shape tapers to a point at the tail, eliminating any overlap or accidental leg snags. The dual-density foam construction has the added benefit of being extremely comfortable. Feeling more like a well-cushioned pair of running shoes, the upper layer provides support and insulation while the firmer sole layer aids traction and durability. These are so comfortable to walk in, we even enjoyed running in them on snowy trails.

Ease of Use

The Crescent Moon EVA Foam features a streamlined and simple binding system that is extremely easy to use. Two velcro straps secure the mid and forefoot, and a third velcro strap wraps around the heel. This is one of the simplest binding systems of any snowshoe we tested, but it is still secure and comfortable. 

We didn’t have any slipping or discomfort even while running (yes, you read that right). By forgoing complex engineering for simplicity, the EVA Foam is accessible and easy to use for any experience level while still ensuring a comfortable, secure fit.

Should You Buy the cRESCENT mOON eVA fOAM?

The Crescent Moon EVA Foam snowshoes are a unique product that fits a very specific niche. Their super-rockered design is very walkable and even great for running, but they sacrifice flotation and traction in deep snow.

If you’re looking for a lightweight, affordable, and easy-to-use snowshoe, then this is a perfect choice. Best for a few inches of fresh snow, this makes a good option for beginners or those staying on packed trails. 

Those looking for a backcountry-ready option may not find these to be the best fit, but they are great for quick outings closer to the well-traveled path.

What Other Snowshoes Should You Consider?

If you’re looking for something a little more traditional or with more float, check out these options from our best snowshoes gear guide:

Tubbs Flex RDG Review: With its flexible frame, the Flex RDG also offers excellent walkability, but with improved traction.

MSR Lightning Ascent Review: If the Crescent Moon EVA Foams left you wanting more flotation, then it’s hard to beat the Lightning Ascent.

Tubbs Xplore Review: At an identical price, the Xplore offers the flotation performance of a tube-style frame at an approachable price.